RNA sequences that direct selective ADAR editing from a SELEX library bearing 8-azanebularine.

Adenosine Deaminases Acting on RNA (ADARs) catalyze the deamination of adenosine to inosine in double-stranded RNA (dsRNA). ADARs' ability to recognize and edit dsRNA is dependent on local sequence context surrounding the edited adenosine and the length of the duplex. A deeper understanding of how editing efficiency is affected by mismatches, loops, and bulges around the editing site would aid in the development of therapeutic gRNAs for ADAR-mediated site-directed RNA editing (SDRE). Here, a SELEX (systematic evolution of ligands by exponential enrichment) approach was employed to identify dsRNA substrates that bind to the deaminase domain of human ADAR2 (hADAR2d) with high affinity. A library of single-stranded RNAs was hybridized with a fixed-sequence target strand containing the nucleoside analog 8-azanebularine that mimics the adenosine deamination transition state. The presence of this nucleoside analog in the library biased the screen to identify hit sequences compatible with adenosine deamination at the site of 8-azanebularine modification. SELEX also identified non-duplex structural elements that supported editing at the target site while inhibiting editing at bystander sites.

Structural and functional effects of inosine modification in mRNA.

Inosine (I), resulting from the deamination of adenosine (A), is a prominent modification in the human transcriptome. The enzymes responsible for the conversion of adenosine to inosine in human mRNAs are the ADARs (adenosine deaminases acting on RNA). Inosine modification introduces a layer of complexity to mRNA processing and function, as it can impact various aspects of RNA biology, including mRNA stability, splicing, translation, and protein binding. The relevance of this process is emphasized in the growing number of human disorders associated with dysregulated A-to-I editing pathways. Here, we describe the impact of the A-to-I conversion on the structure and stability of duplex RNA and on the consequences of this modification at different locations in mRNAs. Furthermore, we highlight specific open questions regarding the interplay between inosine formation in duplex RNA and the innate immune response.

Impact of Disease-Associated Mutations on the Deaminase Activity of ADAR1.

The innate immune system relies on molecular sensors to detect distinctive molecular patterns, including viral double-stranded RNA (dsRNA), which triggers responses resulting in apoptosis and immune infiltration. Adenosine Deaminases Acting on RNA (ADARs) catalyze the deamination of adenosine (A) to inosine (I), serving as a mechanism to distinguish self from non-self RNA and prevent aberrant immune activation. Loss-of-function mutations in the ADAR1 gene are one cause of Aicardi Goutières Syndrome (AGS), a severe autoimmune disorder in children. Although seven out of the eight AGS-associated mutations in ADAR1 occur within the catalytic domain of the ADAR1 protein, their specific effects on the catalysis of adenosine deamination remain poorly understood. In this study, we carried out a biochemical investigation of four AGS-causing mutations (G1007R, R892H, K999N, and Y1112F) in ADAR1 p110 and truncated variants. These studies included adenosine deamination rate measurements with two different RNA substrates derived from human transcripts known to be edited by ADAR1 p110 (glioma-associated oncogene homologue 1 (hGli1), 5-hydroxytryptamine receptor 2C (5-HT2cR)). Our results indicate that AGS-associated mutations at two amino acid positions directly involved in stabilizing the base-flipped conformation of the ADAR-RNA complex (G1007R and R892H) had the most detrimental impact on catalysis. The K999N mutation, positioned near the RNA binding interface, altered catalysis contextually. Finally, the Y1112F mutation had small effects in each of the assays described here. These findings shed light on the differential effects of disease-associated mutations on adenosine deamination by ADAR1, thereby advancing our structural and functional understanding of ADAR1-mediated RNA editing.

Library Screening Reveals Sequence Motifs That Enable ADAR2 Editing at Recalcitrant Sites.

Adenosine deaminases acting on RNA (ADARs) catalyze the hydrolytic deamination of adenosine to inosine in duplex RNA. The inosine product preferentially base pairs with cytidine resulting in an effective A-to-G edit in RNA. ADAR editing can result in a recoding event alongside other alterations to RNA function. A consequence of ADARs' selective activity on duplex RNA is that guide RNAs (gRNAs) can be designed to target an adenosine of interest and promote a desired recoding event. One of ADAR's main limitations is its preference to edit adenosines with specific 5' and 3' nearest neighbor nucleotides (e.g., 5' U, 3' G). Current rational design approaches are well-suited for this ideal sequence context, but limited when applied to difficult-to-edit sites. Here we describe a strategy for the in vitro evaluation of very large libraries of ADAR substrates (En Masse Evaluation of RNA Guides, EMERGe). EMERGe allows for a comprehensive screening of ADAR substrate RNAs that complements current design approaches. We used this approach to identify sequence motifs for gRNAs that enable editing in otherwise difficult-to-edit target sites. A guide RNA bearing one of these sequence motifs enabled the cellular repair of a premature termination codon arising from mutation of the MECP2 gene associated with Rett Syndrome. EMERGe provides an advancement in screening that not only allows for novel gRNA design, but also furthers our understanding of ADARs' specific RNA-protein interactions.

Selective Inhibition of ADAR1 Using 8-Azanebularine-Modified RNA Duplexes.

Adenosine deaminases acting on RNA (ADARs) are RNA editing enzymes that catalyze the hydrolytic deamination of adenosine (A) to inosine (I) in dsRNA. In humans, two catalytically active ADARs, ADAR1 and ADAR2, perform this A-to-I editing event. The growing field of nucleotide base editing has highlighted ADARs as promising therapeutic agents while multiple studies have also identified ADAR1's role in cancer progression. However, the potential for site-directed RNA editing as well as the rational design of inhibitors is being hindered by the lack of detailed molecular understanding of RNA recognition by ADAR1. Here, we designed short RNA duplexes containing the nucleoside analog, 8-azanebularine (8-azaN), to gain insight into molecular recognition by the human ADAR1 catalytic domain. From gel shift and in vitro deamination experiments, we validate ADAR1 catalytic domain's duplex secondary structure requirement and present a minimum duplex length for binding (14 bp, with 5 bp 5' and 8 bp 3' to editing site). These findings concur with predicted RNA-binding contacts from a previous structural model of the ADAR1 catalytic domain. Finally, we establish that neither 8-azaN as a free nucleoside nor a ssRNA bearing 8-azaN inhibits ADAR1 and demonstrate that the 8-azaN-modified RNA duplexes selectively inhibit ADAR1 and not the closely related ADAR2 enzyme.

Nucleoside analogs in ADAR guide strands targeting 5'-UA̲ sites.

Adenosine deaminases that act on RNA (ADARs) can be directed to predetermined sites in transcriptomes by forming duplex structures with exogenously delivered guide RNAs (gRNAs). They can then catalyze the hydrolytic deamination of adenosine to inosine in double stranded RNA, which is read as guanosine during translation. High resolution structures of ADAR2-RNA complexes revealed a unique conformation for the nucleotide in the guide strand base paired to the editing site's 5' nearest neighbor (-1 position). Here we describe the effect of 16 different nucleoside analogs at this position in a gRNA that targets a 5'-UA̲-3' site. We found that several analogs increase editing efficiency for both catalytically active human ADARs. In particular, 2'-deoxynebularine (dN) increased the ADAR1 and ADAR2 in vitro deamination rates when at the -1 position of gRNAs targeting the human MECP2 W104X site, the mouse IDUA W392X site, and a site in the 3'-UTR of human ACTB. Furthermore, a locked nucleic acid (LNA) modification at the -1 position was found to eliminate editing. When placed -1 to a bystander editing site in the MECP2 W104X sequence, bystander editing was eliminated while maintaining on-target editing. In vitro trends for four -1 nucleoside analogs were validated by directed editing of the MECP2 W104X site expressed on a reporter transcript in human cells. This work demonstrates the importance of the -1 position of the gRNA to ADAR editing and discloses nucleoside analogs for this site that modulate ADAR editing efficiency.

ADAR activation by inducing a syn conformation at guanosine adjacent to an editing site.

ADARs (adenosine deaminases acting on RNA) can be directed to sites in the transcriptome by complementary guide strands allowing for the correction of disease-causing mutations at the RNA level. However, ADARs show bias against editing adenosines with a guanosine 5' nearest neighbor (5'-GA sites), limiting the scope of this approach. Earlier studies suggested this effect arises from a clash in the RNA minor groove involving the 2-amino group of the guanosine adjacent to an editing site. Here we show that nucleosides capable of pairing with guanosine in a syn conformation enhance editing for 5'-GA sites. We describe the crystal structure of a fragment of human ADAR2 bound to RNA bearing a G:G pair adjacent to an editing site. The two guanosines form a Gsyn:Ganti pair solving the steric problem by flipping the 2-amino group of the guanosine adjacent to the editing site into the major groove. Also, duplexes with 2'-deoxyadenosine and 3-deaza-2'-deoxyadenosine displayed increased editing efficiency, suggesting the formation of a Gsyn:AH+anti pair. This was supported by X-ray crystallography of an ADAR complex with RNA bearing a G:3-deaza dA pair. This study shows how non-Watson-Crick pairing in duplex RNA can facilitate ADAR editing enabling the design of next generation guide strands for therapeutic RNA editing.

Rational Design of RNA Editing Guide Strands: Cytidine Analogs at the Orphan Position.

Adenosine Deaminases Acting on RNA (ADARs) convert adenosine to inosine in double stranded RNA. Human ADARs can be directed to predetermined target sites in the transcriptome by complementary guide strands, allowing for the correction of disease-causing mutations at the RNA level. Here we use structural information available for ADAR2-RNA complexes to guide the design of nucleoside analogs for the position in the guide strand that contacts a conserved glutamic acid residue in ADARs (E488 in human ADAR2), which flips the adenosine into the ADAR active site for deamination. Mutating this residue to glutamine (E488Q) results in higher activity because of the hydrogen bond donating ability of Q488 to N3 of the orphan cytidine on the guide strand. We describe the evaluation of cytidine analogs for this position that stabilize an activated conformation of the enzyme-RNA complex and increase catalytic rate for deamination by the wild-type enzyme. A new crystal structure of ADAR2 bound to duplex RNA bearing a cytidine analog revealed a close contact between E488, stabilized by an additional hydrogen bond and altered charge distribution when compared to cytidine. In human cells and mouse primary liver fibroblasts, this single nucleotide modification increased directed editing yields when compared to an otherwise identical guide oligonucleotide. Our results show that modification of the guide RNA can mimic the effect of hyperactive mutants and advance the approach of recruiting endogenous ADARs for site-directed RNA editing.

Regulation of RNA editing by intracellular acidification.

The hydrolytic deamination of adenosine-to-inosine (A-to-I) by RNA editing is a widespread post-transcriptional modification catalyzed by the adenosine deaminase acting on RNA (ADAR) family of proteins. ADAR-mediated RNA editing modulates cellular pathways involved in innate immunity, RNA splicing, RNA interference, and protein recoding, and has been investigated as a strategy for therapeutic intervention of genetic disorders. Despite advances in basic and translational research, the mechanisms regulating RNA editing are poorly understood. Though several trans-acting regulators of editing have been shown to modulate ADAR protein expression, previous studies have not identified factors that modulate ADAR catalytic activity. Here, we show that RNA editing increases upon intracellular acidification, and that these effects are predominantly explained by both enhanced ADAR base-flipping and deamination rate at acidic pH. We also show that the extent of RNA editing increases with the reduction in pH associated with conditions of cellular hypoxia.

Ester modification at the 3' end of anti-microRNA oligonucleotides increases potency of microRNA inhibition.

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are short noncoding RNAs that play a fundamental role in gene regulation. Deregulation of miRNA expression has a strong correlation with disease and antisense oligonucleotides that bind and inhibit miRNAs associated with disease have therapeutic potential. Current research on the chemical modification of anti-miRNA oligonucleotides (anti-miRs) is focused on alterations of the phosphodiester-ribose backbone to improve nuclease resistance and binding affinity to miRNA strands. Here we describe a structure-guided approach for modification of the 3'-end of anti-miRs by screening for modifications compatible with a nucleotide-binding pocket present on human Argonaute2 (hAgo2). We computationally screened a library of 190 triazole-modified nucleoside analogs for complementarity to the t1A-binding pocket of hAgo2. Seventeen top scoring triazoles were then incorporated into the 3' end of anti-miR21 and potency was evaluated for each in a cell-based assay for anti-miR activity. Four triazole-modified anti-miRs showed higher potency than anti-miR21 bearing a 3' adenosine. In particular, a triazole-modified nucleoside bearing an ester substituent imparted a nine-fold and five-fold increase in activity for both anti-miR21 and anti-miR122 at 300 and 5 nM, respectively. The ester group was shown to be critical as a similar carboxylic acid and amide were inactive. Furthermore, anti-miR 3' end modification with triazole-modified nucleoside analogs improved resistance to snake venom phosphodiesterase, a 3'-exonuclease. Thus, the modifications described here are good candidates for improvement of anti-miR activity.

High-throughput mutagenesis reveals unique structural features of human ADAR1.

Adenosine Deaminases that act on RNA (ADARs) are enzymes that catalyze adenosine to inosine conversion in dsRNA, a common form of RNA editing. Mutations in the human ADAR1 gene are known to cause disease and recent studies have identified ADAR1 as a potential therapeutic target for a subset of cancers. However, efforts to define the mechanistic effects for disease associated ADAR1 mutations and the rational design of ADAR1 inhibitors are limited by a lack of structural information. Here, we describe the combination of high throughput mutagenesis screening studies, biochemical characterization and Rosetta-based structure modeling to identify unique features of ADAR1. Importantly, these studies reveal a previously unknown zinc-binding site on the surface of the ADAR1 deaminase domain which is important for ADAR1 editing activity. Furthermore, we present structural models that explain known properties of this enzyme and make predictions about the role of specific residues in a surface loop unique to ADAR1.

DNA capture by a CRISPR-Cas9-guided adenine base editor.

CRISPR-Cas-guided base editors convert A•T to G•C, or C•G to T•A, in cellular DNA for precision genome editing. To understand the molecular basis for DNA adenosine deamination by adenine base editors (ABEs), we determined a 3.2-angstrom resolution cryo-electron microscopy structure of ABE8e in a substrate-bound state in which the deaminase domain engages DNA exposed within the CRISPR-Cas9 R-loop complex. Kinetic and structural data suggest that ABE8e catalyzes DNA deamination up to ~1100-fold faster than earlier ABEs because of mutations that stabilize DNA substrates in a constrained, transfer RNA-like conformation. Furthermore, ABE8e's accelerated DNA deamination suggests a previously unobserved transient DNA melting that may occur during double-stranded DNA surveillance by CRISPR-Cas9. These results explain ABE8e-mediated base-editing outcomes and inform the future design of base editors.

Asymmetric dimerization of adenosine deaminase acting on RNA facilitates substrate recognition.

Adenosine deaminases acting on RNA (ADARs) are enzymes that convert adenosine to inosine in duplex RNA, a modification that exhibits a multitude of effects on RNA structure and function. Recent studies have identified ADAR1 as a potential cancer therapeutic target. ADARs are also important in the development of directed RNA editing therapeutics. A comprehensive understanding of the molecular mechanism of the ADAR reaction will advance efforts to develop ADAR inhibitors and new tools for directed RNA editing. Here we report the X-ray crystal structure of a fragment of human ADAR2 comprising its deaminase domain and double stranded RNA binding domain 2 (dsRBD2) bound to an RNA duplex as an asymmetric homodimer. We identified a highly conserved ADAR dimerization interface and validated the importance of these sequence elements on dimer formation via gel mobility shift assays and size exclusion chromatography. We also show that mutation in the dimerization interface inhibits editing in an RNA substrate-dependent manner for both ADAR1 and ADAR2.

Chemical Profiling of A-to-I RNA Editing Using a Click-Compatible Phenylacrylamide.

Straightforward methods for detecting adenosine-to-inosine (A-to-I) RNA editing are key to a better understanding of its regulation, function, and connection with disease. We address this need by developing a novel reagent, N-(4-ethynylphenyl)acrylamide (EPhAA), and illustrating its ability to selectively label inosine in RNA. EPhAA is synthesized in a single step, reacts rapidly with inosine, and is "click"-compatible, enabling flexible attachment of fluorescent probes at editing sites. We first validate EPhAA reactivity and selectivity for inosine in both ribonucleosides and RNA substrates, and then apply our approach to directly monitor in vitro A-to-I RNA editing activity using recombinant ADAR enzymes. This method improves upon existing inosine chemical-labeling techniques and provides a cost-effective, rapid, and non-radioactive approach for detecting inosine formation in RNA. We envision this method will improve the study of A-to-I editing and enable better characterization of RNA modification patterns in different settings.

Versatile 3' Functionalization of CRISPR Single Guide RNA.

Specific applications of CRISPR/Cas genome editing systems benefit from chemical modifications of the sgRNA. Herein we describe a versatile and efficient strategy for functionalization of the 3'-end of a sgRNA. An exemplary collection of six chemically modified sgRNAs was prepared containing crosslinkers, a fluorophore and biotin. Modification of the sgRNA 3'-end was broadly tolerated by Streptococcus pyogenes Cas9 in an in vitro DNA cleavage assay. The 3'-biotinylated sgRNA was used as an affinity reagent to identify IGF2BP1, YB1 and hnRNP K as sgRNA-binding proteins present in HEK293T cells. Overall, the modification strategy presented here has the potential to expand on current applications of CRISPR/Cas systems.

RNA binding candidates for human ADAR3 from substrates of a gain of function mutant expressed in neuronal cells.

Human ADAR3 is a catalytically inactive member of the Adenosine Deaminase Acting on RNA (ADAR) protein family, whose active members catalyze A-to-I RNA editing in metazoans. Until now, the reasons for the catalytic incapability of ADAR3 has not been defined and its biological function rarely explored. Yet, its exclusive expression in the brain and involvement in learning and memory suggest a central role in the nervous system. Here we describe the engineering of a catalytically active ADAR3 enzyme using a combination of computational design and functional screening. Five mutations (A389V, V485I, E527Q, Q549R and Q733D) engender RNA deaminase in human ADAR3. By way of its catalytic activity, the ADAR3 pentamutant was used to identify potential binding targets for wild type ADAR3 in a human glioblastoma cell line. Novel ADAR3 binding sites discovered in this manner include the 3'-UTRs of the mRNAs encoding early growth response 1 (EGR1) and dual specificity phosphatase 1 (DUSP1); both known to be activity-dependent immediate early genes that respond to stimuli in the brain. Further studies reveal that the wild type ADAR3 protein can regulate transcript levels for DUSP1 and EGR1, suggesting a novel role ADAR3 may play in brain function.

Off-Target Editing by CRISPR-Guided DNA Base Editors.

Base editing is a genome editing strategy that induces specific single-nucleotide changes within genomic DNA. Two major DNA base editors, cytosine base editors and adenine base editors, that consist of a Cas9 protein linked to a deaminase enzyme that catalyzes targeted base conversion directed by a single-guide RNA have been developed. This strategy has been used widely for precise genome editing because, unlike CRISPR-Cas nuclease-based genome editing systems, this strategy does not create double-strand DNA breaks that often result in high levels of undesirable indels. However, recent papers have reported that DNA base editors can cause substantial off-target editing in both genomic DNA and RNA. The off-target editing described in these studies is primarily independent of guide RNA and arises from the promiscuous reactivity of the deaminase enzymes used in DNA base editors. In this Perspective, we discuss the development of DNA base editors, the guide RNA-independent off-target activity reported in recent studies, and strategies that improve the selectivity of DNA base editors.

Nucleoside analogs in the study of the epitranscriptome.

Over 150 unique RNA modifications are now known including several nonstandard nucleotides present in the body of messenger RNAs. These modifications can alter a transcript's function and are collectively referred to as the epitrancriptome. Chemically modified nucleoside analogs are poised to play an important role in the study of these epitranscriptomic marks. Introduced chemical features on nucleic acid strands provide unique structures or reactivity that can be used for downstream detection or quantification. Three methods are used in the field to synthesize RNA containing chemically modified nucleoside analogs. Nucleoside analogs can be introduced by metabolic labeling, via polymerases with modified nucleotide triphosphates or via phosphoramidite-based chemical synthesis. In this review, these methods for incorporation of nucleoside analogs will be discussed with specific recently published examples pertaining to the study of the epitranscriptome.